×

Kirsty Birkett begins a new two-part series on Christianity and magic.

There has been a long enmity between Christianity and magic, and for good reason: both Old Testament and New are clear that magic and divination are forbidden. Christians are not to look to magic spells for protection, to cure illness, or do anything else; they are not to try to tell the future using spirits, fortune telling or any other means. Although magicians were fairly common in the ancient world, available for hire, Christians have always been taught to reject their methods. Christians were not to use the spells that are recorded in papyri of the time; spells to heal illness, pronounce curses on others or protect from evil spirits. Christians have always rejected magic.

Exorcism Basilica Di San Zeno Maggiore

Jesus the Magician?

Or have they? There’s a lot of controversy over this: indeed, there’s a long tradition that says the Bible is not against magic, at least not in any straightforward way. For instance, some people in New Testament times, saw Jesus just as another travelling magician, doing magical healings and exorcisms.[1] A number of scholars have tried to interpret Jesus in these terms too.[2] The historian Morton Smith energised the “Jesus as magician” movement in 1978, claiming that Jesus was a magician because he did the things described in magical papyri of the time—healings and exorcisms.[3]

These arguments might appear to have a superficial validity. People certainly saw Jesus as a source of magical power. As we see in the Book of Acts, and in some of the later magical papyri, people tried to use the name of Jesus in magic to perform exorcisms or other rites.[4]

Jesus—Power Without Magic

But the fact that Jesus did some things that magicians also wanted to do does not prove that he was acting like a magician. The influence probably went the other way: the practitioners who put the magical papyri together may well have copied Jesus. Jesus, as presented in the gospels, is notably different from ancient magicians: he didn’t use any of the artifacts—bowls, amulets, herbs etc.—listed for use in ancient magic. He didn’t use incantations—long series of words, calling upon multiple supernatural beings, with mysterious untranslatable magic words. In fact, Jesus’ words in Aramaic in Mark 5:41 and 7:34 may well have been translated specifically so that readers would know they are not magic words. Jesus simply commanded, and it happened (as the centurion recognised, in Matthew 8:5-13 and Luke 7:1-10).

Power over Spirits

Similarly, in exorcisms Jesus’ commands to the “daimons”—unclean spirits – were extremely brief; he didn’t need magic words, or to call upon the names of deities. He simply commands the spirits to go. Once they were gone, too, they were gone for good; he did not provide amulets or other protection from them coming back, as found frequently in ancient magic. The way demons reacted to him is similar to how they were meant to react to magical rings or amulets; Jesus himself was infused with power.

Jesus, in his exorcisms, was no doubt familiar with what other exorcists attempted to do. In his lack of artifice, and his words spoken with personal authority, he subverted the rationale of such exorcists; proving that he was God, he did not need magic. Jesus made the claim that his exorcisms signified the coming of the kingdom of God (Luke 11:20). In contrast, contemporary exorcisms were not considered signs of the coming of the kingdom of God.[5] This is part of how Jesus, and the gospel writers, shows he is different from the ancient magic workers, and his understanding of what he was doing is different.

Opponents of Magic

Jesus and the apostles, in contrast to magicians, are portrayed as staunch opponents of magic; they were—not magicians themselves. As Luke demonstrates, the differences are obvious: magicians exalt themselves and try to misappropriate authority (Acts 8:18-19; 19:13-14); they seek to turn people away from the word of God. But Christian leaders, on the other hand, bring glory not to themselves but God, so that people will believe the word and thereby gain release from Satan’s authority. Even the demons testify to the difference between Christian leaders and magicians (Acts 19:15).  

The  context in which the apostles’ miracles are presented, and the explanation of them, has to be taken seriously. Simon in Acts 8 is rejected because he has fundamentally misunderstood what supernatural power is for. He wants the power for his own ends, rather than proclaim the good news because it is the good news. Bar-Jesus in Acts 13 was not simply defeated in a magical power-struggle; the symbolism of his punishment is significant. He was blind to the gospel, so received physical blindness as well. It is notable that in Acts 12 Barnabas and Paul could have assumed the role of magicians, avatars of Zeus and Hermes, but they did not, instead proclaiming the living God.

Jesus: Majesty, not Magic

In the end, the fact that Jesus is God is what makes the fundamental difference between him and the magicians. The power is actually his—and is loaned to his apostles. Ultimately, what Jesus’ power demonstrates is not his skill in wielding it, nor even his strength, although both of those also mark him out against ancient magicians. The key thing about Jesus’ power is that he brings in the resurrection age.

Jesus’ Power and Christian Confidence

Jesus’ resurrection gives us the primary context for understanding where Christians stand in relation to magic. In his death and resurrection, Jesus defeated the powers of evil that were called upon for magic. As the resurrected ruler of the universe, he stands in triumph over them. Anyone who belongs to Christ need not fear magic, and has no need for magic; every Christian already has every spiritual blessing (Eph 1:3). Being in Christ truly does cast out all fear: the fear that magic might otherwise have addressed. Jesus is risen and victorious, and the future hope he points to is certain.

Jesus came to a world that believed in magic; a world in which ghosts and spirits were dangerous, and interacted with people. Some of what he did is understood in this context. But he wasn’t a magician—he was God incarnate. He defeated the magical powers so that those who shared in him and his Spirit, could no longer be dominated by them. He told the truth about these powers. He made magical ritual unnecessary, because the new life he offered had acceptance by God as its cornerstone.

Adapted from Kirsten Birkett, Spells, Sorcerers and Spirits: Magic and the Occult in the Bible (London: Latimer, 2015).
Available www.latimertrust.org.


Photos: Babak Fakhamzadeh, Darren and Brad(inset); flickr.com

[1] Justin Martyr (110-165) defends Christ against this charge in his first Apology, XXX. See online http://www.newadvent.org/fathe…

[2] See David E. Aune ‘Magic in early Christianity’, Aufstieg und Niedergang der Roemischen Welt, II vol 23.2, 1980, pp. 1507-1557.

[3] Morton Smith, Jesus the Magician (New York: Harper and Row, 1978); see also his Clement of Alexandria and a Secret Gospel of Mark (Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press, 1973).

[4] See Hans Dieter Betz (ed), The Greek Magical Papyri in Translation, Including the Demotic

Spells, 2nd ed, (Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press, 1992), pp. 307, 323.

[5] Graham H. Twelftree, ‘Jesus the exorcist and ancient magic’, in Labahn and Peerbolte (eds), A Kind of Magic, pp. 57-86, p. 85, note 140.

LOAD MORE
Loading